Headless Horseman

Join our mailing list!

By joining our mailing list you will received advanced notification of all the latest happenings in Sleepy Hollow. From cemetery tours to how to a legendary Halloween celebration Sleepy Hollow style. Don't miss out!







You are here: Home > Gifts Ideas
Sort By:
Page of 2
Gift Certificates - Multiple Denominations

Add a gift certificate to your cart you will then be prompted to change the dollar amount.
Pewter Sleepy Hollow Spoon
Our Price: $8.95

Another Sleepy Hollow Gifts Online EXCLUSIVE! Well-made keepsake spoon is 4-1/2" inches tall and has same graphic as our pewter magnet and pewter keychain cast in the top portion of the handle: the headless horseman and "Sleepy Hollow, New York." This is a great gift for anybody who collects keepsake spoons!
Sleepy Hollow Collectible Thimble
Our Price: $8.95

Sleepy Hollow pewter collectible thimble. 3/4" tall. Features colorful depiction of the Headless Horseman in hot pursuit of poor Ichabod. Made in USA.
Headless Horseman Knit Cap
Our Price: $15.00

Protect your head in the Hollow with these fashionable knit hats. We hear the horseman is attracted to uncovered heads. Comes in tan, gray or black.
Headless Horseman Knit Cap with cuff
Our Price: $15.00

Protect your head in the Hollow with these fashionable knit hats. We hear the horseman is attracted to uncovered heads. Comes in slate blue, green, burgundy or black.
Headless Horseman hat - black
Our Price: $17.95

Our black hat features a fearsome Headless Horseman ready to hurl a Jack O'Lantern. With pumpkin in orange and headless horseman in white and black thread, this is a very distinctive hat. It's all we can do to keep family and friends from "borrowing" samples.
Headless Horseman hat - khaki
Our Price: $17.95

Our new khaki hat features a fearsome Headless Horseman poised to hurl a Jack O'Lantern. Pumpkin appears in orange thread (naturally!), horseman in white and black thread. Also available on black and burnt orange hats. Fabric hideaway closure with brass buckle for adjustable fit. 100% cotton, low-profile hat is embroidered here in New York state, USA. As with most of our wares, you'll find this Headless Horseman hat only at Sleepy Hollow Gifts Online and our seasonal table outside the south gate to Sleepy Hollow Cemetery in Sleepy Hollow, New York.
Headless Horseman, Sleepy Hollow NY T-Shirt, black
Our Price: $21.95

Our new headless horseman t shirt is 100% cotton and is quickly becoming a best seller!
Sleepy Hollow Necklace - Clear Glass Pumpkin Bead
Our Price: $23.95

This unique medallion is made right here in Sleepy Hollow by a local artist. The face features a headless horseman, the reverse reads "The Legend of Sleepy Hollow." It's strung on a leather necklace and accented by a clear pumpkin bead. Medallion is 7/8" diameter. The back of the mounting card has information about Washington Irving, The Legend of Sleepy Hollow, and the artist.
Sleepy Hollow Necklace - No Bead
Our Price: $23.95

This unique medallion is made right here in Sleepy Hollow by a local artist. The face features a headless horseman, the reverse reads "The Legend of Sleepy Hollow." It's strung on a leather necklace. Medallion is 7/8" diameter. The back of the mounting card has information about Washington Irving, The Legend of Sleepy Hollow, and the artist.