Headless Horseman

Join our mailing list!

By joining our mailing list you will received advanced notification of all the latest happenings in Sleepy Hollow. From cemetery tours to how to a legendary Halloween celebration Sleepy Hollow style. Don't miss out!







You are here: Home > Pewter
Sort By:
Page of 1
Pewter Sleepy Hollow Pin
Our Price: $5.95
This solid pewter rendition of the Headless Horseman poised to hurl a pumpkin is the same design as our popular key chain and magnet on a smaller scale. Measures 1 inch by 3/4 inch.
Pewter Sleepy Hollow Magnet
Our Price: $6.95
One of our most popular products! Adds a certain sense of the macabre to the shopping list on the refrigerator. Solid pewter rendition of the Headless Horseman poised to hurl a pumpkin.
Pewter Sleepy Hollow Key Chain
Our Price: $6.95
Very similar to our Oval Pewter Magnet only this has the story of the Horseman on the back. Use it with your car keys and keep an eye on the rear view mirror. 3 3/4" x 1 1/4" including the key ring.
Brushed pewter photo keyring
Our Price: $7.95
Sleepy Hollow Headless Horseman Keyring
Keep the Headless Horseman with you wherever you go! 2" x 3 3/4" including key ring




Pewter Sleepy Hollow Spoon
Our Price: $8.95
Another Sleepy Hollow Gifts Online EXCLUSIVE! Well-made keepsake spoon is 4-1/2" inches tall and has same graphic as our pewter magnet and pewter keychain cast in the top portion of the handle: the headless horseman and "Sleepy Hollow, New York." This is a great gift for anybody who collects keepsake spoons!
Pewter Old Dutch Church Ornament
Our Price: $18.95
A Sleepy Hollow Gifts Online EXCLUSIVE! This is our pewter rendition of the church from The Legend of Sleepy Hollow. Looks great year round, and especially at Halloween. Ornament has "Old Dutch Church Sleepy Hollow, New York" engraved on front and "circa 1685" on the back. Pewter. Made in the USA.
Pewter Headless Horseman Ornament
Our Price: $18.95
Solid pewter of the Horseman in full gallop, pumpkin in hand. A Sleepy Hollow Gifts Online EXCLUSIVE. Well made in the USA.
Belt Buckles
Our Price: $21.95
Sleepy Hollow Belt Buckles
Hold up your pants and the Headless Horseman won't let you down! Our custom made belt buckles come in 2 colors - brushed pewter or brass and 2 shapes - oval or rectangular. Oval measures 2 7/8" across x 2" high. Rectangular is 3" across x 2" high. Please specify color and a shape.
Pewter Headless Horseman Statue
Our Price: $39.95
A Sleepy Hollow Gifts Online EXCLUSIVE. This is a must for all Headless afficianados. Shows the Horseman in full gallop, orange pumpkin held high. Has "The Headless Horseman of Sleepy Hollow, New York" along the base. Well made in the USA. 4" x 3 1/2"