Headless Horseman

Join our mailing list!

By joining our mailing list you will received advanced notification of all the latest happenings in Sleepy Hollow. From cemetery tours to how to a legendary Halloween celebration Sleepy Hollow style. Don't miss out!







You are here: Home > For the Holidays
Sort By:
Page of 2
Pewter Sleepy Hollow Pin
Our Price: 5.95

This solid pewter rendition of the Headless Horseman poised to hurl a pumpkin is the same design as our popular key chain and magnet on a smaller scale. Measures 1 inch by 3/4 inch.
Sleepy Hollow Collector's Bell
Our Price: 5.95

Same design as our collectible pewter thimble, this collectible bell is 1 1/2 inches tall
OUT OF STOCK
Sleepy Hollow Thimble
Our Price: 7.95

Sleepy Hollow pewter collectible thimble. 3/4" tall. Features colorful depiction of the Headless Horseman in hot pursuit of poor Ichabod.

Made in USA.
Sleepy Hollow Headless Horseman Ornament
Brushed pewter photo ornament
Our Price: 7.95

Easy to keep up all year long as a Sleepy Hollow reminder. 2" wide x 2.5" high. Comes with ribbon


White Glass Sleepy Hollow Ornament
Our Price: 9.95

Our classic glass globe features the Headless Horseman with orange pumpkin held aloft. Text reads "The Legend Lives, Sleepy Hollow, New York."
Back in stock!!
Headless Horseman Knit Cap
Our Price: 15.00

Protect your head in the Hollow with these fashionable knit hats. We hear the horseman is attracted to uncovered heads. Comes in tan and gray.
Headless Horseman Knit Cap with cuff
Our Price: 15.00

Protect your head in the Hollow with these fashionable knit hats. We hear the horseman is attracted to uncovered heads. Comes in slate blue  and green.
Pewter Old Dutch Church Ornament
Our Price: 18.95

A Sleepy Hollow Gifts Online EXCLUSIVE! This is our pewter rendition of the church from The Legend of Sleepy Hollow. Looks great year round, and especially at Halloween. Ornament has "Old Dutch Church Sleepy Hollow, New York" engraved on front and "circa 1685" on the back. Pewter. Made in the USA.
Pewter Headless Horseman Ornament
Our Price: 18.95

Solid pewter of the Horseman in full gallop, pumpkin in hand. A Sleepy Hollow Gifts Online EXCLUSIVE. Well made in the USA.
Headless Horseman, Sleepy Hollow NY T-Shirt, black
Our Price: 19.95

Our new headless horseman t shirt is 100% cotton and is quickly becoming a best seller!